Receiver Noise Canceller
Iulian Rosu , YO3DAC / VA3IUL, http://www.qsl.net/va3iul
Receiver Noise Cancellers, using an additional receive antenna to phase out the
local noise, were invented during the tube era, before WW2.
Several manufacturers make this kind of noise cancellers for radio amateurs (S.E.M., MFJ, WiMo, Timewave, DX Engineering). Their block diagram is almost the same, but the approach of the circuit implementation is different. Whatever complexity their circuit has, the noise canceling performances are pretty similar.
Unfortunately all of these devices suffer from dealing with high input signals.
canceller presented bellow mainly improves the IP3 linearity of the circuit.
linearity is done by using on each antenna path (main and noise) two J310 JFETs
in parallel which are DC supplied at relative high voltage (+20V).
Compared to a single J310 JFET supplied at +12V, a stage using two JFETs in parallel supplied at +20V have more than 6dB better IP3 performance. Also this approach has higher gain and lower noise figure, parameters which are important for a first stage amplifier in a receiver system.
The signal from the main antenna is routed to the circuit through a steep elliptic High Pass Filter with cut-off at 2.9 MHz, filter which rejects strong broadcast stations and high noise levels below that frequency. Further, the signal is amplified by the Q1, Q2 stage.
The signal from the Noise antenna it goes initially to the phase changer circuit, and later amplified by the stage Q3, Q4 JFETs.
Drains of all JFETs Q1, Q2, Q3, and Q4 are connected together, connection where we get the sum of the Main and Noise signals.
the Noise Gain and Noise Phase potentiometers, attain the noise null.
adjusting the amplitude and the phase of the signals coming from the Main and
Noise antennas, you can get an enhancement of the desired signals. This is an
advantage which otherwise you get if using two paralleled receivers connected to
different antennas. This is an option that some high-price transceivers have.
properly, very important is to use for the “Noise” antenna an antenna similar
with the "Main" antenna. Some manufacturers mistakenly mention that the “Noise”
antenna should be a simple wire or a simple loop antenna. Generally can be used
any “Noise” antenna but I found that the best performances were obtained when
the antennas are similar in size and polarization. The main reason of this
situation is because the Noise doesn’t have to be local in origin; it can also
arrive by ionospheric propagation from distant sources. This effect can allow
noise from sources very far away to accumulate at the receiving location and
"mask" the weak signals.
distance between antennas should be λ/2 or greater. Due to limited space
sometime this distance is hard to get in 80m and 40m, but the circuit it will
work sufficient well even the antennas are closer. The noise canceling
performance is not affected much by the distance between antennas, but the
signal enhancement option could be affected.
On the schematic, the two relays are shown in receive mode, which means: Switch 1 is closed, and the PTT of the transceiver is not pushed (PTT line not connected to the ground). R state of the relays means release state (when the circuit is not DC supplied, and Switch 1 is open).
reliability of the circuit it is very important to use fast
signal relays, with switching (operate) time less than 5msec (most of the
modern signal relays does this).
Important to don’t damage the circuit with high RF power is: Never transmit with the transceiver if the PTT line from the transceiver is not connected to the circuit. If forget to do this connection and transmit 100W, the JFETs Q1,Q2,Q3,Q4 and diodes D3, D4 will be most probably damaged (due to high level of standing waves inside of the box). To prevent this situation I placed the LED1 into the circuit, to check always if the PTT cable coming from the transceiver is connected to the circuit. When the PTT from the transceiver is not pushed (RX mode), most of the transceivers put +8V on the PTT line. This DC voltage is used to light on the LED1.
For minimum loss of TX power when passing through the noise canceller circuit, on the back panel of the device place the TRX connector near the Main antenna connector, and place the relay RLY1 between them. Use short 50 ohms coax cables (4mm diameter with PTFE dielectric).
Never place the Noise Canceller circuit after a high power amplifier (more than
If use an external Transmatch, I would recommend placing the Noise Canceller circuit between the Transmatch and the Antenna, even some manufacturers recommend to be placed between the Transceiver and the Transmatch.
Also I recommed to tune the Transmatch (internal or external) with the Noise Canceller circuit not DC supplied (Switch 1 open), and switch ON the device after the tuning is done.
phasing transformer Tr1 was made on a
ferrite toroid, having 16 turns on primary and 4 turns on secondary.
Here is a short movie which shows the performance of the Noise Canceller device. Can be seen on the waterfall the noise reduction and improved signal readability when the device is active or is not.