ChatGPT on 20-7-2025

Refering to opportunities to improve the didactic flow:

I would agree that Ch. 5 & 6 “Preface” but placed after Ch. 4. and by doing so it may interrupt the flow of "foundational science." 

I would suggest to change the title of Ch.3 to "Why Forecast bands conditions."
Additionallt modify the content of Ch3. to explain how forecasting relies on understanding the ionosphere and solar activity.

What do you think?



* Suggestion: Move them earlier, e.g., after Ch. 1 or combine as one “Fundamentals of the Ionosphere”.

2. Chapter 3 (Forecasting) appears too early.

* 

* Suggestion: Move Chapter 3 after Chapters 5–9. Then the reader first learns what affects propagation, and only then how to forecast it.

3. Overlap between Chapters 11–13:

* These three chapters all address global solar/geomagnetic influences. Some topics appear split across them.

* Suggestion: Consider merging or streamlining to reduce redundancy.

4. Chapter 14 (Radio blackouts) is quite short and could logically be part of Ch. 13 or a broader section on disruptions and anomalies.

Suggested new order for better didactic flow:

1. Introduction

2. Ch. 1 – Basics of HF Propagation

3. Ch. 5 & 6 – The Sun and the Ionosphere (moved up and merged as "Ionospheric Physics")

4. Ch. 4 – HF Propagation Modes

5. Ch. 7 – Ionospheric Influence & Conditions

6. Ch. 8 – Regional HF Conditions

7. Ch. 9 – Ionospheric Dynamics

8. Ch. 10 – Total Electron Content (TEC)

9. Ch. 3 – Forecasting HF Conditions (moved here)

10. Ch. 11–13 – Global HF Conditions + Solar/Geomagnetic Effects

11. Ch. 14 – Radio Blackouts (fold into Ch. 13 or extend as a dedicated disruptions chapter)

12. Ch. 2 – Monitoring Band Activity (this is more practical, so it might work better later or in an appendix)

13. Summary, Glossary, References

____________________

Are there important topics not covered?


Yes — a few advanced or related topics are missing or noted as omitted:

📌 Not currently covered (but important):

* Auroral propagation

* Tropospheric scatter

* Meteor scatter

* Backscatter

* EME (moon bounce)

These modes are explicitly mentioned as out-of-scope in Chapter 4, but they could be added as appendices or a future “Advanced Propagation Modes” chapter.

----

Additional suggested topics:

1. Polar Cap Absorption (PCA): Briefly mentioned, but could benefit from its own explanation.

2. HF propagation in polar vs equatorial regions: Geographic nuances are hinted at but not deeply explored.

3. Propagation reliability and noise analysis: There's some mention of SNR, but no detailed treatment.

4. Impact of man-made noise and QRM: Important for practical operating, especially for urban radio hams.

___________________

Conclusion and Recommendation

Your guide is well-organized and impressively comprehensive for most amateur-level and intermediate needs. With minor reordering for pedagogical clarity and the addition of some advanced topics, it could become an even more robust reference.

Would you like me to help you produce a revised table of contents based on these suggestions?
_________________________________________________________