[SI-LIST] : coming up with average power estimates for buffers

Pat Zabinski ([email protected])
Mon, 2 Aug 1999 10:57:01 -0500

I'm working on a rather large system (over 50,000 Watts!), and we
are trying to come up with some detailed power estimates for
each component.

The system is essentially comprised of LOTS(!) of identical
parallel processing ASICs, each ASIC having roughly 600 I/O.
The basic I/O is full-swing CMOS with a 2.5 VDD supply running
at roughly 100 Mbps. A small change in one ASIC will have
a three-orders of magnitude higher impact on the system, so we need
to pay very close attention to details. The I/O have been
designed and tweaked to account for impedance, edge rates,
packaging effects, etc., so we have a high level of confidence
they are going to work; at this point, we simply need to
obtain a power estimate for them.

In order to come up with good system-level power estimates (which
will determine cooling requirements and power supply requirements),
we need to have an accurate ASIC power estimate. We've got pretty
good numbers for the core circuitry, but we're trying to develop
an estimate for the custom I/O buffers.

To get the power for one buffer, we simulate the buffer with
a 1010101... pattern, toggling every possible bit period.
The buffer is loaded with an average-length transmission
line, and we use spice to plot the power vs time for at
least two bit-transitions. Overall, we get a power
vs time plot that is relatively flat except during the logic
transitions (no surprise here), and the peaks vary in amplitude
depending upon a rising or falling edge.

In the past, we have used the "simple average" power, meaning
taking the integral of the power over two bit periods (to ensure
we've captured one falling and one rising edge)and dividing
it by the time. We have used this figure as
our average power for the worst-case-bit-pattern.

However, a colleague recently suggested using the "RMS average"
of the power, which is computed slightly differently. For our
case, the RMS average resulted in a power estimate that was
50% higher than the average value.

>From my experience, taking the integral of the power curve will
result in the effective energy consumed by the buffer, and dividing
this by the time will provide the average power. However,
RMS is used so frequently in power estimates, I could not provide
a good answer why it shouldn't be used.

Can anyone tell me how to best determine the average power
for a buffer? Am I anywhere on the right track? Which is better,
simple average or RMS average?

One other point to note: as we increase the transmission line
length, the RMS power goes up as well (as expected). However,
this trend continues to a certain point, then the power actually
reduces with increased line length. Can someone explain why
the RMS power would be reduced with increased length? We're only
seeing a small percentage change (~10-20%), but it's got
me curious.

Pat Zabinski

  Pat Zabinski                                     ph: 507-284-5936
  Mayo Foundation                                  fx: 507-284-9171
  200 First Street SW                     [email protected]
  Rochester, MN 55905       www.mayo.edu/sppdg/sppdg_home_page.html

**** To unsubscribe from si-list: send e-mail to [email protected] In the BODY of message put: UNSUBSCRIBE si-list, for more help, put HELP. si-list archives are accessible at http://www.qsl.net/wb6tpu/si-list ****