Re: [SI-LIST] : Different board vendors different impedances

Laurence Michaels (lmichael@techmail.gdc.com)
Wed, 24 Mar 1999 13:51:43 -0500

Katie Rothstein wrote:
>
> Laurence,
> Just a quick thought about your question. Different board vendors have
> different processing capabilities (line width, total board thickness, board
> size, etc.) This could be why some board shops can meet your required
> impedances and some cannot. I'm not sure exactly what you are asking about the
> different calculations, but many board houses have impedance calculation tools
> that take empiricle data to help make corrections for their own processes.
> -Katie

It sometimes seems that, even with 'equivalent' processes, allowing the
same board thickness, size, line width, and layer stackup, board vendors
will come up with different values for trace impedance, generally
requiring them to tweak the board stackup. Since we sometimes like to
use different board vendors, even on the same board, it would be nice to
be able to specify FR4 and copper, and use only one layer stackup,
instead of having to keep track of which vendors require which different
dielectric heights. It would be even better to come up with a
theoretical calculation that works in practice, since some people seem
to think that anything should be able to be calculated without having to
add tweak factors for different vendors. I'm beginning to realize that
this is not the case.

What I'd really like is to come up with a set of layer stackups, perhaps
including different stack heights for different vendors, for a few
different controlled impedances and numbers of layers. Doesn't seem too
likely, as even including the true dielectric constant for the specific
vendor's material in the calculation doesn't always come out within 10%
of the measured impedance. Plus I'd rather only have one layer stackup
(including diel. heights) per board, regardless of vendor. Wishful
thinking...

I'd also like a less expensive way to measure trace impedance than a
TDR, so that we can check the board vendor's claims ourselves. Any
ideas here?

-- Laurence

**** To unsubscribe from si-list: send e-mail to majordomo@silab.eng.sun.com. In the BODY of message put: UNSUBSCRIBE si-list, for more help, put HELP. si-list archives are accessible at http://www.qsl.net/wb6tpu/si-list ****