Some
general comments on antennas
-
Analyze your antenna first. Use at least two different programs, if possible,
to confirm the results.Better 10 hours
on computer than an hour on the tower.
-
No coax losses on HF bands are negligible (see table below)
-
No connector losses on HF bands are negligible
-
SWR alone does not explain antenna properties
There
is a good reason to climb the tower if the initial SWR is 1:2. If the antenna
shows a SWR of 1:1.3, leave it. Measure both impedance components, if possible,
and use Smith chart to explain what is the matter.
Comments
on Commercial Antennas
Hams
living within cities and urban lots are often unable to erect a tower with
a regular Yagi or Quad. Experiments with wires may require a lot of space
so many Hams "ending" with a multiband vertical antenna. Regardless of
wide availability of many types of such antennas the answer to the question
"what antenna should I buy" is not simple.
Avoid
a "no radial" vertical
A
multiband vertical is always shortened on some bands and is "full sized"
mostly only on 28 MHz. A non radial type which does not count on the mirror
image building up the virtual half of the radiator and seems then more
shortened than a classic one using radials. No radial. antennas
may serve as emergency solution that has no access to the roof and must
do all within own apartment... "Balcony Hams" may utilize advantages of
such radiators using this antenna mounted on the balcony fence anchored
to the wall by two non conducting ropes at angle of about 45 degrees. What
a rocky way to the DX world!
Tuning
problems
Antenna
manufacturers advertise their products as perfectly tuned, some providing
tuning possibility by varying of the radiator length, rare exception are
tunable traps (as I know the only is Hy-Gain DX-88). It is strongly recommended
to obtain a detailed manual before antenna purchase. The resonant frequency
is strongly dependent on the antenna environment and grounding system (radials).
You may find SWR graphs for CW, low phone and high phone tuning. Tests
confirmed that all antennas were pre-tuned to SSB band portions. If you
hate SSB, you may became disappointed with first results and tired
with up-down procedure needed for proper adjustments to make it work on
other modes
Summary:
Any
antenna is pre-tuned to SSB band portions.
Do
not attempt to adjust the antenna without a good impedance analyzer (MFJ-259B
recommended).
Cheap
materials and poor fabrication
When
purchasing a new antenna, take a look at the parts. If you find sharp edges
or the tubing full of metal scraps, you need a bit of power to assemble
two parts together, it is a sign of poor fabrication. Do not be blamed
with "famous" product mark, a well known manufacturer may produce a poorly
fabricated model.
Another
problem is a cheap material used for construction. Some manufacturers using
a thermoplastic material for trap coil forms. It may melt easily if applied
power exceeding some 500-700 Watts (noted such problems on the Hy-Gain
DX-88, do not be blamed if the traps looking very heavy - it is the gimmick
plast only, inside you may find a coil wound of relatively thin wire and
the encapsulated trap prevents any air exchange for sufficient cooling).
If tubular capacitors used in traps, the dielectric insert may smoke up
quickly if applied power exceeds the above mentioned level (noted such
problems on the Cushcraft AP8-A). Select an antenna with heavy tubular
air capacitors (without any plast dielectric insert). The capacitors should
be well protected from moisture, dust and insects.
Pay
attention to the clamps and screws used - the hardware should be always
made of stainless steel. If you plan to buy an expedition antenna, which
should be assembled and disassembled many times, self-cutting screws may
cause problems.
Ensure
yourself about availability and quality of manufacturer’s customer support.
Remember
that applying of the legal limit power may become an "infernal" test. If
your life is too short for QRP, use antennas with heavy traps where is
easy a replacement with Teflon custom made coil form.